Violence: A Gendered By Product of Disaster

by Jacqui Patterson

As hurricane season draws to a close and the 5th anniversary of the Tsunami approaches, we are preparing to engage in UN high level talks on climate change in Copenhagen. Beginning the 16 Days of Activism on violence against women and girls comes at an opportune time because analysis of all of the aforementioned events leads to an examination of the impact of disaster and climate change in elevating occurrences of violence against women and girls as well as heightening risk for HIV&AIDS which is directly linked to violence and many of the same factors that contribute to violence. In times of disaster, insecurity and instability combine with high levels of stress, economic duress, dearth of counseling, substance abuse, and lack of protectionism, to render a situation resulting in increased vulnerability to violence and HIV&AIDS for women and girls.

“I am 17 years old. In the relief camp when I was sleeping in the night, I was raped. I did not know what had happened to me. I had heavy bleeding. Now I see some disturbances in my body and when my mother took me to hospital I was told I am pregnant.” A woman in India interviewed in a Tsunami humanitarian assistance camp (1).

In the United States, where I live, Hurricane Katrina was a stark demonstration of the differential impact of disaster on women and particularly women of color, as it relates to violence.  A friend of mine was among the throngs of people, primarily African American due to the structural inequalities that rendered them disproportionately immobilized, taking refuge in the New Orleans Superdome. She told of the chilling sound of the screams of women she heard echoing through the building while she sat terrified both for herself and for the fate of one of her sisters.  Though little data is available, the anecdotal accounts of sexual and physical violence are many.

I’m crying as I write….I found out two days ago that Charmaine Neville, like hundreds of other women, was raped during the storm.” —Shana Griffin, New Orleans Women’s Health Clinic (2). 

Given the elevated risk of contracting HIV during coerced or forced sex, due to lack of use of prevention methods, it is important to keep in mind this intersecting hazard when considering the differential dangers faced by women and girls in disaster situations..

Other disasters have documented incidence of domestic violence associated with severe weather events. Police reports of domestic violence following the eruption of Mt. St. Helen's in 1980 increased by 46% (3).  Directly after the 1993 floods in Missouri, the turn-away rate at domestic violence shelters rose 111%  (4)  and the Montreal police department reported that 25% of calls received during the ice storm of 1997 were from women experiencing abuse (5).    After Hurricane Mitch, in Nicaragua 30% of community leaders and 42% of the mayors interviewed reported increased battery (6).

The trajectory we find ourselves on with escalating climate change finds us facing the current and growing specter of increased occurrence of severe weather events and resulting disasters. Thus, at global, national, and local levels, we must prepare ourselves for by making sure disaster preparedness, response, recovery, and reconstruction policies and programs are designed to address the differential impact on women and girls, with requisite resource allocation, as well as strengthening community based prevention and responses.

“I’m not interested in any action plan to rebuild/organize a people’s agenda in New Orleans without a gender analysis and a demand for community accountability.”—Shana Griffin

Jacqui Patterson is the Co-Founder and Coordinator of Women of Color United as well as the Director of the Climate Justice Initiative at the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP).

Endnotes

(1) Violence Against Women in the Post Tsunami Context, People’s Report—India, the Maldives, Puntland (Somalia), Sri Lanka, and Thailand (2007) www.actionaid.org
(2)  To Render Ourselves Invisible, What Lies Beneath: Katrina, Race, and the State of the Nation: Edited by the South End Press Collective. Cambridge, MA: South End Press (2007) www.southendpress.com
(3)  Kirsty, Duncan. Global Climate Change and Women’s Health.  http://www.redorbit.com/news/health/890479/global_climate_change_and_womens_health/index.html#
(4) Godina, Victoria and Colleen Coble. 1995. The Missouri Model: The Efficacy of Funding Domestic Violence Programs as (5) Long-Term Disaster Recovery. Final Evaluation Report, December 1995. Jefferson City, Missouri: The Missouri Coalition Against Domestic Violence.   Facts about Post Disaster Domestic Violence. Lutheran Disaster Relief of New York. http://www.ldrny.org/TOPNEWS/materials/DVfacts.pdf
(6)  Social Audit for Emergency and Reconstruction, Phase 1—April. Study conducted by the Coordinadora Civil para la Emergencia y la Reconstrucción (CCER), Managua, Nicaragua. CIET international (www.ccer-nic.org/doc/htm). 1999
----------
Watch out for our daily blogs during the 16 days of Activism:
 
25 Nov - Intensify efforts in ending all forms of violence against women and girls (Shamillah Wilson, South Africa)
26 - Are All Defenders Equal? (Cynthia Rothschild, New York, USA)
27 - Give me back my movement! (Everjoice J. Win, Zimbabwe)
28 - An essential package of services to deal with two interlinked human rights and rights crises. (Neelanjana Mukhia, India)
29th - Questions of accountability and violence against women and girl and HIV&AIDS. (Shamillah Wilson, South Africa)
30th - Female Condoms: Now More Than Ever. (Kimberley Whipkey, USA)
1st Dec - Violence of Judgementalism (Meena Saraswathi Seshu, India)
2nd - Violence, A Gendered By Product of Disaster (Jacqui Patterson, USA)
3rd - Silenced Links: Violence and HIV in Women. A current look at Latin America and the Caribbean. (Mabel Bianco, Argentina)
4th - Sexist Violence. Some Data to take into consideration. (Nirvana Gonzalez Rosa, Puerto Rico/Chile)
5th - Sex Workers. Sex Worker Rights. (Aziza Ahmed, USA)
Rights Not Rescue. Experiences of Sex Workers in Southern Africa. (Vicci Tallis, South Africa)
6th - Criminalisation of HIV and concerns for violence against women. (Norah Matovu Winyi, Kenya)
7th - Issues of violence against lesbian women and lesbian, bi- and transsexual women. (Vicci Tallis, South Africa)
8th - Violence against women in conflict situations. (Mary Wandia - Kenya and Neelanjana Mukhia - India)
9th - Today the enemy is homosexual. Tomorrow it could be you. (Christine Butegwa, Uganda)
10th - Our work isnt done - response to VAW as a consequence of HIV (Neelanjana Mukhia, India)
-------
The Women WON'T wait. End HIV and Violence Against Women. NOW. Campaign is an international coalition of organizations and networks working to promote women's health and human rights in the struggle to address HIV and AIDS and end all forms of violence against women and girls.
 
Members of the campaign are: Action Aid; African Women’s Development and Communications Network (FEMNET); Association for Women’s Rights in Development (AWID); Akina Mama wa Afrika; Center for Women’s Global Leadership (CWGL); Center for Health and Gender Equity (CHANGE); Fundación para Estudio e Investigación de la Mujer (FEIM); GESTOS-Soropositividade, Comunicação & Gênero; International Community of Women Living with HIV&AIDS Southern Africa (ICW-Southern Africa); International Women’s AIDS Caucus; International Women’s Health Coalition (IWHC); Latin American and Caribbean Women’s Health Network; Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa (OSISA); Program on International Health and Human Rights, Harvard School of Public Health; SANGRAM; VAMP; and Women and Law in Southern Africa (WLSA).
 
Become a fan of our facebook page: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Women-Wont-Wait-Campaign-End-HIV-and-Violence-Against-Women-NOW/192809781054?ref=ts

 


 

 
Design by Ideosphere